This content has affiliate links. When you buy through these links, we might earn one affiliate commission.

You are watching: Why did frodo have to leave the shire


Where did Frodo go? (Where didn’t Frodo go? but seriously.) go Frodo dice at the end of the books? Let’s gain into it. This post will, of course, contain spoilers for The lord of the rings (books and also movies).

*
Where walk Frodo walk at the end?

Frodo goes come the Undying Lands v the elves. If the mortal human, hobbit, and dwarf personalities discuss death and also dying (and perform plenty that it) in Lord that the Rings, the immortal elves don’t talk about their finish in the very same manner in ~ all.

Galadriel explains it in The Fellowship the the Ring after ~ Frodo offers her the One Ring and also she chooses not to accept: “I will diminish, and go into the West, and remain Galadriel.” Her use of the word diminish suggests a change, if not death itself. (This line is similar in the book and the movie.)


What space the Undying Lands?

According come The lord of the ring Wiki:

“The Undying Lands were a realm lived in by Ainur and also Eldar. The area consisted of the continent that Aman and the island that Tol Eressëa. The s Belegaer be separate the Undying Lands native the west shores that Middle-earth. Just immortals and also ring-bearers were allowed to live in this realm.”


Swords & Spaceships Newsletter
Sign as much as Swords & Spaceships to receive news and recommendations from the people of scientific research fiction and fantasy.
Thank you for signing up! store an eye on her inbox.
By signing increase you agree to our regards to use

Why does Frodo leave Middle-earth?

Frodo is tired. Frodo has actually been with the gauntlet and suffered tremendously. The elves market him a reward because that his bravery as ring bearer (a reward also given to Bilbo, and later come Samwise).

Frodo explains his an option to Sam in the book The Return of the King:


“But I have been as well deeply hurt, Sam. I tried to conserve the Shire, and it has actually been saved, but not because that me. That must regularly be so, Sam, as soon as things room in danger: some one has to offer them up, lose them, so the others might keep them.”

He likewise says: “I to be wounded, wounded; that will never ever really heal.” This argues that continuing to be in Middle-earth—living—is as well difficult.

Does Frodo dice at the end?

Maybe.

Gandalf says, in the book: “Well, right here at last, too ~ friends, ~ above the shores of the Sea comes the end of our fellowship in Middle-earth. Walk in peace! I will not say: execute not weep; for no all tears are an evil.”

His lines space slightly different in the movie:

“Farewell, mine brave Hobbits. My work-related is currently finished. Below at last, ~ above the shores of the sea, come the end of ours Fellowship. I will not say carry out not weep, for not all tears space an evil.”

The conversation continues, wherein it does no in the book (borrowing words from elsewhere in the book):

Gandalf: it is time, Frodo.Sam: What does that mean?Frodo: We set out to save the Shire, Sam. And also it has been saved, but not because that me.

Theory One: Frodo lives in the Undying Lands

“Frodo, you just threw the One Ring right into the fiery pits the Mordor, what room you walking to execute next?”“I’M GOING come DISNEYLAND!”

Okay, the isn’t an exact quote; it’s something Patricia Elzie-Tuttle claimed to me together a joke. However it is precious considering what sort of price the Undying floor are.

In the movie The Return of the King, we check out Sam take it Frodo to satisfy the elves in ~ the port (aka the Grey Havens), whereby he is rejoined with Bilbo. They space both clearly alive! Frodo and Bilbo sail v the elves and Sam returns home. While the is no explicitly declared that they stay alive, we do not check out them die; we see them accurate sail away.

Theory Two: Frodo Dies and also the Undying Lands are Heaven

Although Tolkien swore up and also down that The mr of the Rings was no allegory, it was undeniably full of metaphor.

After the goodbyes ~ above the shore, Sam the town hall Frodo go:

“Then, Frodo kissed Merry and also Pippin, and last of every Sam, and also went abroad; and the sails were attracted up, and also the wind blew, and also slowly the ship slipped away under the long grey firth; and the light of the glass that Galadriel the Frodo bore glimmered and also was lost. And also the delivery went out right into the High Sea on into the West, till at critical on a night the rain, Frodo smelled a sweet fragrance on the air and heard the sound of singing that came over the water. And then it seemed to him together in his dream in the house of Bombadil, the grey rain-curtain turned every to silver glass and also was rolled back, and he beheld white shores and also beyond castle a much green nation under a swift sunrise.

But come Sam the evening deepened to darkness as he stood at the Haven; and as the looked in ~ the grey sea that saw just a shadow on the waters the was soon shed in the West. There still that stood much into the night, hearing only the sigh and also murmur that the waves on the shores of Middle-Earth, and the sound of lock sank deep into his heart. Beside him stand Merry and also Pippin, and they to be silent.”

If the isn’t a an allegory for death, i don’t believe there has ever been one. Especially specific is the line: “the irradiate of the glass of Galadriel that Frodo boring glimmered and also was lost.” certainly it walk not appear to Sam that Frodo was any longer in this world—though the is no inconsistent through the idea that he left Middle-earth.

Despite not explicitly showing Frodo die, the movie suggests—in dialogue in between Gandalf and also Pippin—that going come the Undying floor is without doubt what happens once you die:

Pippin: ns didn’t think it would finish this way.Gandalf: End? No, the trip doesn’t end here. Death is just another path. One that we all have to take. The grey rain-curtain the this people rolls back, and also all transforms to silver- glass. And also then you watch it.Pippin: What? Gandalf? view what?Gandalf: White shores…and beyond, a far green country under a swift sunrise.Pippin: Well, that isn’t for this reason bad.Gandalf: No…No it isn’t.

A Conclusion…of Sorts

I cannot tell you how to translate the publications or the movies. I could tell you what i think, however I’d quite tell you this: everything you believe, the is what happened.

See more: Q Sufficient Dietary Carbohydrates Prevent Excess Formation Of What?

*

And a short article Script

In postposition B: The tale of year (Chronology that the Westlands), “Later Events worrying the Members of the Fellowship of the Ring” in The Return the the King (book), it is revealed that after plenty of years of life in Middle-earth, Legolas built a watercraft in Ithilien and also sailed native the Grey Havens to the Undying Lands, bringing with him his dear girlfriend Gimli (the only dwarf ever to go to the Undying Lands).