Elad Dvash-Banks, left, and Andrew Dvash-Banks with their pair sons, Aiden, left, and Ethan in your apartment in Los Angeles critical year.Credit...Jae C. Hong/Associated Press

Aiden and Ethan Dvash-Banks are twin brothers who were born minute apart.

You are watching: Is one of the les twins gay

But only among them was considered to it is in a United states citizen through the State Department. A federal judge rule this week the was a mistake.

The twins space the young of 2 married happy men, an American citizen and an Israeli citizen. Aiden to be conceived utilizing sperm from his American father and also Ethan to be conceived utilizing sperm native his Israeli father, court documents show. A surrogate mother gave birth come the guys in Canada in 2016.

The household sued the State Department for denying Ethan citizenship, illustration attention come a department plan that states that a kid born abroad should be biologically regarded an American parent to become a citizen. Gay civil liberties activists said that the policy damages same-sex couples, who often use assisted reproductive modern technology to have actually children.

“Two youngsters who have practically identical life experiences and parenting,” said Aaron C. Morris, a lawyer because that the family and the executive director of immigrant Equality, a legitimate advocacy group that operated on the case. “To law them in different way is absurd.”


In a judgment on Thursday, Judge man F. Walter of commonwealth District Court for the central District the California stated that Ethan must be known as a citizen since birth. The judge ruled the federal law does not require a son born come married parents to prove a organic relationship with both parents.

The State Department said in a explain on Friday that it to be reviewing the ruling, however did not respond to questions around what the would median for the policy going forward.

The twins, currently 2 year old, to be born to Andrew Dvash-Banks, an American citizen, and Elad Dvash-Banks, one Israeli citizen. The pair met in Israel and also married in Canada in 2010 before having their sons v the aid of helped reproductive technology, follow to their lawsuit.

After the twins were born, their parents went to the United says Consulate in Toronto to certify the children’s American citizenship and also get United says passports. Yet they to be told the the twins had actually to take it a DNA check to prove a genetic connection to Andrew, the sue said.

Ethan to be denied citizenship due to the fact that Andrew was not his organic father, follow to a copy of a letter native the State Department had in the lawsuit.


“If us were a straight pair and i was an Israeli woman and both of our names to be on both kids’ bear certificates, would you ever before require united state to do a DNA test?” Elad said in a video about the instance posted by the immigrant advocacy group.

When the Dvash-Bankses made decision to move to Los Angeles come be near Andrew’s family in 2017, same-sex marriage had been legalized and also three that the four family members members to be eligible to live in the joined States. However Ethan was enabled into the nation only top top a tourist visa, i beg your pardon expired the December, follow to the lawsuit.

The couple sued the State room the following month, with the help of immigration Equality, the legal advocacy group, which functions on instead of of L.G.B.T. Immigrants and also their families.

Mr. Morris, the group’s executive, management director, said that Ethan to be living together an undocumented infant in California, i beg your pardon caused daily anxiety for the family and made it an overwhelming for that to gain to understand his prolonged family in Israel.

“It take it a really long time before he gained to accomplish his grandparents,” Mr. Morris said. “When lock did their taxes, lock didn’t have a Social protection number because that Ethan. Enrolling him in day care was complicated. This to be an everyday frustration.”

In his judgment this week, judge Walter called the State Department’s translate of the citizenship law “strained.”

But the judgment stopped short of striking down the State Department’s policy over all and also does not necessarily use to various other families, follow to Mr. Morris. Immigrant Equality is fighting a comparable case in Washington on instead of of a same-sex couple living in London.


Mr. Morris stated he hope the judgment would it is in “persuasive” to other courts and would probably compel the government to adjust its plan voluntarily.

“It is one an ext in a series of cases telling the State Department that they are acquiring the plan wrong,” the said.

For the Dvash-Bankses, at least, the ruling brought fast relief. Afterward, Elad and also Andrew told their toddlers the news, together the guys chomped ~ above bananas and also smiled.

See more: How Many Tsp Is 7.5 Ml Are In A Teaspoon? Measurement Of Medicines

“Not discovering whether Ethan would certainly be enabled to stay in the U.S. Is miscellaneous we went to bed with every night,” Andrew said in a statement approve by the advocacy group.