Why bother Potter Movies readjusted Dumbledore's fatality (& Made it Worse) The bother Potter movies made some transforms to the biggest scenes native the books, including Dumbledore"s death – and also actually made it worse.

You are watching: Does dumbledore die in the half blood prince


Although the Harry Potter movie series did a great job in adapting J.K. Rowling Wizarding civilization to the huge screen, it had to either omit or change many scenes to better fit the format – and likewise for dramatic purposes. Such is the instance of the death of Albus Dumbledore in Harry Potter and also the Half-Blood Prince, which was adjusted in means that fans weren’t completely on plank with and also that in reality hurt the scene.

Readers about the people were presented to the Wizarding civilization in 1997, once Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone was published. The publication was adhered to by six more, telling the story that “the boy that lived” and also his battle versus the darkest magician of all: mr Voldemort. The publications were later adjusted into eight movies (with Harry Potter and also the Deathly Hallows being split into two), bringing the world of bother Potter to a new audience. As it happens through every cinematic adaptation the a book, plenty of characters, scenes, and events to be left out of the movies, and also some others were adjusted for different reasons.


Related: take care of Potter Movies damaged Fred Weasley"s Death

One that the most emotional moment in the Harry Potter series is Dumbledore’s death. The beloved hogwart headmaster and the one wizard Voldemort to be afraid of met his fate in the sixth book, however his fatality in the movie was an extremely different to the one in the source material, and it in reality hurt the original scene.

The real Reason Dumbledore’s fatality Was adjusted In The Movie


Harry Potter Dumbledore fatality Half-Blood Prince
Albus Dumbledore passed away during the battle of the Astronomy Tower (also recognized as the battle of the Lightning-Struck Tower). As Lucius Malfoy failure to attain the prophecy during the battle of the to adjust of Magic, Voldemort notified Draco Malfoy to kill Dumbledore, knowing an extremely well the he couldn’t perform it given that Dumbledore’s power and skills were over his. Narcissa Malfoy, fearing that was every a setup to have actually Malfoy killed in revenge versus Lucius, request Severus Snape to aid Draco and complete the mission if that couldn’t. This transaction was sealed with an Unbreakable Vow.


After obtaining among the horcruxes native a cave, Harry and also Dumbledore returned to Hogsmeade, wherein Madam Rosmerta warned them that the Dark Mark showed up over the Astronomy Tower. Dumbledore and Harry borrowed her broomsticks and headed up there, advertisement Dumbledore immobilized Harry with a silent complete body-bind curse and covered him through the invisibility cloak. Dumbledore climate hid bother in a dark bunker underneath the platform. Draco arrived, along with other death Eaters, however couldn’t lug himself to death Dumbledore. Snape suddenly appeared and, ~ Dumbledore pleaded through him (as to not raise apprehension over Snape’s actual allegiance and also the overall plan), Snape conduct to kill him. The step played out differently in the movie: Snape and Narcissa did have actually a deal, and also Draco was followed by fatality Eaters (though not the exact same ones together in the book), but the remainder was readjusted in methods that no appeal to fans.

See more: Buick Rendezvous Rear Wheel Bearing Replacement Costs, Rear Wheel Bearing Hub Assembly Lr Rr For 03


Dumbledore and also Harry apparated come the height platform of the Astronomy Tower – they never ever came across with Rosmerta, nor to be the Dark note over the tower. Harry no frozen through Dumbledore, and was rather instructed to go and also hide below the platform. Snape suddenly showed up next to Harry and also told that to remain silent, climate proceeded maximum ground to kill Dumbledore. In addition to all that, the battle of the order of the Phoenix versus the death Eaters wasn’t included, together director David Yates want to prevent repetition with the battle of Hogwarts, comes in the eighth movie. That was an extremely out the character for Harry to simply remain quiet and also not do anything when his mentor to be being killed, despite it have the right to be justification by him trusting Snape would never ever kill Dumbledore. No Yates nor anyone else involved in Harry Potter and also the Half-Blood Prince have actually revealed their thinking behind these changes, yet it could simply be because of narrative (and dramatic) purposes, offering Harry more reasons to dislike Snape, together he reliable him to conserve Dumbledore, though it finished up hurting the Dumbledore/Harry dynamic.